Wednesday, August 28, 2013

David Carr Wonders: What Are We Thinking?

The New York Times Media Equation columnist David Carr may be stumbling toward your humble blogger’s conclusion of last month that Fear in the Fourth Estate is Good.

Carr reports with wonder, the rancor establishment journalists clearly feel for the likes Julian Assange, the WikiLeaks founder who brokered the publication of Bradley Manning’s purloined information, and Glen Greenwald, the Guardian Columnist who broke Eric Snowden’s NSA revelations.

In his previous column on this subject, Carr tried to distinguish between “journalists” and “activists.”  Now he posits an “emerging Fifth Estate composed of leakers, activists, and bloggers who threaten those of us in traditional media.”  These taxonomies are important to Carr because he continues to cling to the notion that journalists, as members of the fourth estate, are a special, legally protected class.

The Fourth Estate is a class of people and institutions with an important but unofficial role in governance.   The fourth estate derives its power from independently supplying citizens with information they want, including information about government which government may wish to withhold.  Originally defined by the technology of printing, the class has expanded to radio, film and TV mediums.  Carr feels he has to invent a Fifth Estate because he is not yet ready to admit Internet upstart leakers, activists, and bloggers to his class.

But Carr feels conflicted.  He quotes Daniel Ellsberg of Pentagon Papers fame as saying “With Snowden in particular you have a split between truly independent journalists and those who are tools- and I mean that in every sense of the term – of the Government.”  Carr suggests that establishment media would win Pulitzers and Peabodies for breaking the same stories that sent Manning to jail and Snowden into comrade Putin's free-press-loving embrace.

At the root of Carr’s dilemma is a common misinterpretation our constitution, which states in its first amendment:

Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.

We have conflated "the press" as a communication technology with 'the press" as a particular class of people engaged in journalism.  “The press” in context of the first amendment is a means of expression, like speech and assembly. It seems unlikely that the authors of the amendment would have penned a reference to a specific class of people between general references to speech and assembly.

Thomas Paine wrote in, “Common Sense,” his pamphlet of 1776, "a long habit of not thinking a thing wrong gives it a superficial appearance of being right."  Our long habit of conflating a communication technology, “the press,” with a political class of people who employ the technology has left us unprepared for the implications of a new communication technology.

When John Peter Zenger, a newspaper printer, was charged, in 1734, with seditious libel for printing stories of corruption involving the Royal Governor of New York, his defense was that he had printed the truth.  According to the Judge, such a defense had no standing in law, but the jury ignored the judge and found Zenger “not guilty.”  Similarly the Judge in the Daniel Ellsberg case made the extra-legal judgment that Ellsberg could not be convicted for telling the truth about government lies.


“What are we thinking?” asks Carr at the close of his column.  But he has already answered his own question.  He portrays an establishment press that feels comfortable with government restrictions but threatened by more courageous competitors.

The cold and harsh reality of the political economic equation is this:  The people’s desire for truth about their government can only be met by a press that is willing to defy their government in order to get it.  Ironically, the only protection the press can have, if it is to function as the fourth estate, is the politically potent power to persuade large numbers of fellow citizens and fellow journalists to stand on the side of truth.

True journalists have to make common cause with truthful leakers, activists, and bloggers. The hacks can serve only as government tools.

Labels: , , , , , , , , ,

Wednesday, July 3, 2013

Why Fear in the Fourth Estate is Good

There a was a remarkably feeble defense of freedom of the press in the “Media Equation" column by David Carr, in the New York Times this Independence Day week, juxtaposing journalists, whom Carr defines as people “responsible for following the truth, wherever it may guide them” and activists whom he defines as people dedicated to “winning an argument.”

“Taxonomy is important,” he writes “…because when it comes to divulging national secrets, the law grants journalists special protections that are granted no one else.”  Mr. Carr cites no law which your humble blogger believes may be due to the fact that no such law exists.  Shield laws in quite a few states favor journalists, but it is through political power not legal code that the press avoids prosecution for disclosure of classified information.
A journalist is simply
“a person engaged in journalism"

A journalist used to be defined as “a person whose occupation is journalism,… the collecting, writing editing and publishing of news or news articles through newspapers or magazines “(per your humble bloggers  hard-used 1969 copy of the American Heritage Dictionary).  Today,  Merriam Webster defines a journalist as “a person engaged in journalism,… the collection and editing of news for presentation through the media”

By higher authority than David Carr, the intent to find truth has not been added to the definition but "occupation" has been broadened to "engaged," "publishing," to "distribution," and "newspapers and magazines" to "media."  In further discussion "news" is also broadened to include “related commentary and feature materials.”

Truth only enters the definition of journalism as a conceit of journalism schools, the University of Minnesota in Mr. Carr’s case, and the marketing position of media such as Mr. Carr’s employer, the New York Times.  What Mr. Carr is apparently trying to do is parse, on the basis of intent, an argument against The Guardian’s reporting by Glenn Greenwald of  Edward Snowden's revelations about the NSA’s use of telephone and internet data.

The NSA revelations are making many in mainstream media uncomfortable.  No one is questioning the truth of the NSA revelations – only the right to voice them.  Mr. Carr’s contortions (although he pretends to concede the point in the column) have to do with claiming, for the New York Times and establishment journalism, the authority to use their own (well-intended and well-informed) editorial judgment about what should be public information while denying the same power to competitors or mere citizens who dare to exercise their own (misguided and argumentative) judgment about what should be public.

The NSA revelations highlight an uncomfortable, larger truth about the modern media equation.  Private speech, personal movement, and media consumption used to be difficult to monitor and relatively simple to protect.  Now, with new information technology, it all has become much harder to defend from prying eyes.  Increasingly we are relying on the good intent of our government and the private companies who can peer into the patterns of our lives.

The broader political-economic equation however, remains grounded in human nature.  Good intent is a weak factor in political-economic calculus whereas self-interest is paramount.

To avoid squirrelly twists like Mr. Carr's, we are better off placing the enlightened self-interest of media elites squarely on the side of free expression, open competition, and a balance of powers.  When it comes to divulging state secrets, members of the media must fear the same risk of prosecution as any citizen activist and be willing to fight for their own and thus everyone's freedom.

It is citizens and journalists, as citizens, that have the responsibility for following truth.  And freedom of public speech, although subject to some limitations, belongs to us all.

Labels: , , , , , , , ,