Wednesday, August 28, 2013

David Carr Wonders: What Are We Thinking?

The New York Times Media Equation columnist David Carr may be stumbling toward your humble blogger’s conclusion of last month that Fear in the Fourth Estate is Good.

Carr reports with wonder, the rancor establishment journalists clearly feel for the likes Julian Assange, the WikiLeaks founder who brokered the publication of Bradley Manning’s purloined information, and Glen Greenwald, the Guardian Columnist who broke Eric Snowden’s NSA revelations.

In his previous column on this subject, Carr tried to distinguish between “journalists” and “activists.”  Now he posits an “emerging Fifth Estate composed of leakers, activists, and bloggers who threaten those of us in traditional media.”  These taxonomies are important to Carr because he continues to cling to the notion that journalists, as members of the fourth estate, are a special, legally protected class.

The Fourth Estate is a class of people and institutions with an important but unofficial role in governance.   The fourth estate derives its power from independently supplying citizens with information they want, including information about government which government may wish to withhold.  Originally defined by the technology of printing, the class has expanded to radio, film and TV mediums.  Carr feels he has to invent a Fifth Estate because he is not yet ready to admit Internet upstart leakers, activists, and bloggers to his class.

But Carr feels conflicted.  He quotes Daniel Ellsberg of Pentagon Papers fame as saying “With Snowden in particular you have a split between truly independent journalists and those who are tools- and I mean that in every sense of the term – of the Government.”  Carr suggests that establishment media would win Pulitzers and Peabodies for breaking the same stories that sent Manning to jail and Snowden into comrade Putin's free-press-loving embrace.

At the root of Carr’s dilemma is a common misinterpretation our constitution, which states in its first amendment:

Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.

We have conflated "the press" as a communication technology with 'the press" as a particular class of people engaged in journalism.  “The press” in context of the first amendment is a means of expression, like speech and assembly. It seems unlikely that the authors of the amendment would have penned a reference to a specific class of people between general references to speech and assembly.

Thomas Paine wrote in, “Common Sense,” his pamphlet of 1776, "a long habit of not thinking a thing wrong gives it a superficial appearance of being right."  Our long habit of conflating a communication technology, “the press,” with a political class of people who employ the technology has left us unprepared for the implications of a new communication technology.

When John Peter Zenger, a newspaper printer, was charged, in 1734, with seditious libel for printing stories of corruption involving the Royal Governor of New York, his defense was that he had printed the truth.  According to the Judge, such a defense had no standing in law, but the jury ignored the judge and found Zenger “not guilty.”  Similarly the Judge in the Daniel Ellsberg case made the extra-legal judgment that Ellsberg could not be convicted for telling the truth about government lies.


“What are we thinking?” asks Carr at the close of his column.  But he has already answered his own question.  He portrays an establishment press that feels comfortable with government restrictions but threatened by more courageous competitors.

The cold and harsh reality of the political economic equation is this:  The people’s desire for truth about their government can only be met by a press that is willing to defy their government in order to get it.  Ironically, the only protection the press can have, if it is to function as the fourth estate, is the politically potent power to persuade large numbers of fellow citizens and fellow journalists to stand on the side of truth.

True journalists have to make common cause with truthful leakers, activists, and bloggers. The hacks can serve only as government tools.

Labels: , , , , , , , , ,

Wednesday, January 19, 2011

Bigger is Better: Why The Media Loves Facebook Stories

It was another big weekend for Facebook stories.  “The Social Network,” won four awards at Critics' Choice Movie Awards last Friday and four more at the Golden Globe Awards Sunday Night.  The movie, which has grossed over $200 million so far, has, according to the LA Times   “won the majority of critics honors this year, including the Los Angeles Film Critics Association., New York Film Critics Circle and National Society of Film Critics.”

Meanwhile, Facebook was given a starring role in the overthrow of Tunisia’s long ruling President, Zine el Abidine Ben.  The LA Times coverage with the head "Tunisia protesters use Facebook, Twitter and YouTube to help organize and report" was typical. 

These stories reinforce a key fact about media economics: there is almost infinite positive return to scale in media. The bigger a story gets, the more profitable it becomes. The massive audience of Facebook makes anything about Facebook into a good story.  And the fact that people follow Facebook stories begets new stories.  Right now, anything with a Facebook angle will get an audience.  Even the mild interest of millions can be powerful.

A big story earlier in the month was the Goldman Sachs investment of $450 million in Facebook implying a $50 Billion valuation of Facebook.  Hefty, though well shy of AOL’s peak of $166 billion before the dot com bust; still a spectacular number for us all to talk about!  It grew to such a big story that Goldman Sachs was forced on Monday to ditch plans to peddle the shares to US clients for fear of triggering a de facto public offering in the eyes of the SEC.

A big story doesn’t have to be true to sell, just good.  Your humble blogger finally saw "The Social Network" with his date, along with a full house, Saturday night.  The story of The Accidental Billionaires is good.  The less juicy story of a prodigy programmer, tutored from childhood, already an entrepreneur and recognized by leading firms and publications while still a student at an elite private prep school, seeped in the academic research of social networks at a top college, quickly recognizing a promising phenomenon and successfully securing access to capital (the most important competitive advantage an early stage company can have) would be a harder sell.

The Facebook story of Tunisia should be tempered by an accounting of TV coverage and of who has the tanks.  We need to look at the political economics, not just the popular narrative.  The New York Times did note in coverage on January 14, that Al Jazeera has been airing nightly coverage of the unrest in Tunisa for the past month and that many in Tunisia “credit Al Jazeera’s broadcasts with forging the sense of solidarity and empowerment that moved Tunisians across the country to take to the streets simultaneously.”  And an article on the 16th noted that General Rachid Ammar, whose “for president” web page had 1,700 “likes” on Facebook (count ‘em) had pulled army tanks and personnel from from downtown Tunis (no count given).

Your humble blogger will leave the big valuation story for others to figure out.  Suffice to say we haven't seen the last chapter.                                                              

The media loves Facebook stories because we all do. Being part of something big whether it is a big event or the next big thing is something most people “like.”

Labels: , , , , ,

Saturday, January 2, 2010

In 2010, Think About the Political Economics of Information

You might say it started with event-magic in 2004, the year Facebook was founded. On a cool, damp July night in Boston, a tall, handsome, (secretly) cigarette-puffing University of Chicago professor-turned-politician, skilled in the ancient art of oratory, delivered his first nationally covered speech.

An estimated 15,000 media representatives were there, looking for a good story, when Barack Obama, then a candidate for the U.S. senate, spoke to about 5,000 delegates at the 2004 Democratic National Convention. And 9.1 million viewers watched on TV.

Fast-forward less than five years and the boyish face of Facebook founder Chris Hughes was cover art for the April issue of Fast Company Magazine with the cut line “The Kid Who Made Obama President.” The “boy wonder” according writer Ellen McGirt, had “changed politics and marketing forever.”

Media—whether old, new, or yet to be invented—are instruments of power. Power is fundamentally rooted in three forces: production, destruction and belief. Productive power creates; destructive power coerces; persuasive power influences our view of the world. And these forces interact. Productive capacity can create destructive weapons. Coercive power can seize the means of production. Beliefs guide production and destruction. The dynamics of such interactions are the stuff of political economy. And media are right in the thick of it.

Belief, a key factor in political economy, is the real business of the media. With information and exhortation, media influence belief, and so direct the use of time and resources—for better or for worse. Media can help motivate altruism or suicide bombings; set styles; sell products or politicians. So as we start the new year, it would behoove those of us who make our living creating and distributing information and entertainment to be more cognizant of political economics.

Economics alone will not determine the future shape of our media businesses. We have plenty to learn from the story of how our President rose so quickly to the highest office in our nation (hint: the Fast Company story is not the last word). And still more to learn from the unfolding drama of his presidency. In 2010, too narrow a focus on economics and the strictly commercial uses of information might cause us to miss opportunities—social and political as well as economic!

We at the Conference Department wish all a peaceful, productive and EVENTFUL 2010.

Labels: , , , ,