Wednesday, March 30, 2011

Face-to-Face is Fundamental

The event slice of the media pie is growing again according to sources recently cited by BtoB and Media Business.  The Center for Exhibition Industry Research (CEIR) reported 2010 increases over 2009 of exhibiting companies, 2.1%; revenue, 4.2%; professional attendance, 5.4%; and net square feet, 5.6%.  Reed Elsevier and United Business Media have been buying events while shedding print properties.  A Communications Industry Forecast from Veronis Suhler Stevenson projects tradeshow spending in excess of B to B e-media and print ad spending by 2014.
 Clay Tablet from Egypt
ca. 2270 BCE.

Apples iPad2 Tablet 2011
 (Courtesy Apple)
Events have been part of the communications mix since before clay tablets. Now we’re all atwitter about tablet computers and smart phones.  New technologies are absolutely transforming communication.  But events will still be important when we are looking at tablet computers in the museum beside the displays of “micro computers" of the late '70s, fax machines and telegraphs.

Events are the original media of one-to-many communication and the original social media.  People are social by nature. We thrive on real social interaction.  Because events are truly interactive, B-to-B media CEO’s, including Bob Carrigan of IDG and David Levin, CEO of UBM, expect events to remain key to their businesses.

Events move minds.  Other media seldom has the same total effect.  Can you recall a recent learning experience you’ve had?  If you are like many people some of your most profoundly moving experiences are associated with events.  You react most strongly when your senses, of sound, sight, tactile feeling and even smell are all engaged.  At an event you are moving around; doing things with other people: asking and answering questions, face-to-face.  Participation motivates and mobilizes us all.

Events build trust.  Trust speeds the development of relationships.  Think of business contacts you’ve made in the past year, how they started, and where they’ve led.  Chances are, while you’ve made new contacts from many sources including online social media, the ones that have progressed most rapidly to mutual benefit began face-to-face.  Trust is also essential to building loyalty for your organization and brand.

Events can make money for you, directly if you are in the media business or indirectly if you use events as a marketing-communication tool.  In either case, amid an ever-widening array of communication options, events remain key to effectively cementing high-value relationships with your audiences or prospective customers.

Events evolve - today’s newest media maybe tomorrow’s clay tablet but face-to-face interaction will never be obsolete.  In the B to B field, email has largely replaced direct mail for attendee promotion and social media has become a significant contributor; virtual technology has become a substitute for some kinds of meetings and lead generation.  Specific forms and business models of events continue to change, but face-to-face persists as a powerful media.  

Face-to face events remain fundamental.   Events must be a primary part of your integrated communication mix, if you’ve got a business message for employees, customers, prospects, or broader audience.  We’d appreciate hearing about your success and your problems with events by comment below or directly by phone or email.

Labels: , , , , ,

Wednesday, November 10, 2010

Seven Quick Ideas on Event Curation

Most people associate “curation” with the art of museum management. Some might mistake it for a method of meat preservation. But curation is now is the term de jour for the process of selecting organizing and presenting content in media and, more broadly, merchandise and even food. Lately it has been used to ennoble the process of making any set of choices that create an experience.

The term “curation” originally appealed to media mavens as a way to impart museum dignity to the process of aggregating online content. In the fashion trades, where your humble blogger suspects the modern usage originated, “curate” is used interchangeably with “edit” as a fancy way to say “select carefully” (see a humorous article about this by Alex Williams last year the NYT).

“Event curation” is worth thinking about even though it might sound a bit pretentious for show biz. After all, creating good events is a lot tougher than lining up a few links or arranging the soft goods “just so.” Whether your event content is entertainment, participation, or information, or some combination of the three, here are seven quick thoughts about event curation:

1. Content ain’t king. It’s a noble and necessary part of a winning event. However, the score of the game is rarely kept in content measures. Know how the score is kept and what your content is expected to accomplish.


2. Start early. Good content takes time to develop and the details cascade into countless other aspects of event execution, especially marketing. You are working to a fixed date. Rushing greatly increases risk.


3. Don’t proceed linearly. Not every avenue of content exploration will pan out. For instance, in an informational event, invite more than one speaker per slot simultaneously so you have options as the program develops.


4. Stay flexible. Take full advantage of the live, real-time nature of events. Build quick reaction into your curation process. Make room for hot developments around your content as well as for the usual problems.


5. Know and believe in your own content. Don’t be afraid to invest in learning. “Content farms” and “conference mills” operate on the theory that content is a low value commodity that is not worth deep consideration or appreciation – it shows in their products.


6. Be a media utilitarian. Incorporate whatever it takes to move minds (and hearts) effectively and make sure every media you use - print, live action, visual display, online, mobile, etc. - works together and really contributes. Don’t waste effort on conventional or wiz-bang stuff that isn’t clearly useful.


7. Focus on the experience. A great concert is tough to enjoy if the seats are uncomfortable or the room is too hot. You may not have control over all elements of an event experience but use your influence to integrate the content into the full experience.


Purposefully creating a full experience is the essence of event curation. Feel free to comment with your ideas and questions.

Labels: , , , , , ,

Tuesday, October 19, 2010

The Bad and the Ugly at the Inbound Marketing Summit

Last week your humble blogger shared some of the smartest things we heard and some of the fun we enjoyed at the Inbound Marketing Summit which we sponsored under our NewMeetia initiative. But I promised the Bad and the Ugly along with the Good.

It was weird to see so many attendees nose-down to their PC
screens. Like students in college lecture halls, many seemed
to be, as we charitably call it, "multi-tasking."
The dumbest thing I heard at the conference was “Scale and media buying power are no longer a decisive advantage.” The speaker was David Meerman Scott, Marketing Strategist, Freshspot Marketing, who, to his credit, was also the source of some smart commentary about "Real-Time Marketing" and some good fun, including the donning of a tie-dye t-shirt (under his sport coat) to flog a book he and Brian Halligan, CEO of Hubspot have put together about “Marketing Lessons of the Grateful Dead.” But the notion that new media negates scale is wishful thinking.

Size matters in media. The technology has changed but not the fundamental political economics of information. Scott’s illustration of how a David can slay Goliath with new media was the oft-repeated story of “United Breaks Guitars,” a video that went viral. What the story actually proves is that the secret to going viral is to get picked up by big media. Scale can fail but, everything else being equal, big is still a better bet. Venture firms have rushed money into selected low/no- revenue new media companies like Facebook and Twitter to gain the decisive advantages of scale. They fully expect a future payoff.

The second dumbest thing we heard is that one can “curate content” with an investment of only 20 minutes a day. The speaker was Pawan Deshpande, CEO of HiveFire. I may be misquoting because what he undoubtedly meant was 20 minutes a day with Curata, a HiveFire service designed to help organizations with content aggregation, production and distribution for marketing purposes (starting at around $1,500 a month).

No one can “curate” anything well without serious contemplation. While the Curata service is currently being used to produce surprisingly good looking online content, (sample here; testimonials on their home page) the implication that a reputation for content can be earned and sustained with a minimal time investment assumes that the “curator” doesn’t need to learn continuously but only needs to tweak search criteria once in a while. Its like bad journalism, automated.  And Deshpande’s concept of “curation” is based on the dubious assumption that people will keep originating and posting worthy content without some system of compensation from content marketers. Real thought leadership requires original thought and research. “Curation” may be the single subject of a future post.

The ugly part of the conference came from speakers who worked too hard to project an anti-establishment, spontaneous and outrageous persona. One’s material has to be good to make the pose work, especially in a business context. Scott Stratten, president of UnMarketing, carried it off most successfully with his harsh critique of conventional marketing. He garnered a lot of laughs and twitter traffic with comments such as “we suck at now, why worry about next?” At times however, some speakers seemed only course and tasteless. One speaker reported her mental reaction to a request for an honest appraisal of her product “I’m on salary, bitches!” Some thoughts are best left unsaid.  Another big name disappointed everyone sitting around me in one session with unprepared prattle and puerile humor from the podium.

The good news is that online social and content marketing are rapidly becoming main-stream. The flip side of becoming main-stream is a new level of accountability for clear thinking, respectful conduct and real results. So another piece of good news is that there is still room for improvement.

Labels: , , , , , , , ,

Thursday, October 14, 2010

The Good, the Bad and the Ugly at the Inbound Marketing Summit

We wanted to share the smartest and the dumbest things we heard at the Inbound Marketing Summit last week – fortunately there was stiff competition for the former. We were one of the sponsors of the event under our newMeetia initiative and we found plenty of value for marketers at the two day event along with a little malarkey and lots of stuff that was just plain fun.

Good Fun: Steve Garfield Helps Us Set a Simultaneous
Video World Record at the Inbound Marketing Summit 

(see http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EqrRjp_CJio)
Clearly, online social and content marketing is now main stream. While some speakers valiantly jousted against straw-man “old marketing” enemies the best presentations were about integrating new online marketing with the old, “inbound”(online-inquiry) with “outbound” and online media with offline. And the rants against self-discipline were more than offset by practical advice about how to measure and manage online marketing.

Mobile and online marketing fit naturally with marketing in other media according to Tim Hayden, Chief Strategy Officer and Partner, Blue Clover Studios. We should keep in mind that “ninety percent of Word of Mouth takes place offline,” he said, citing Keller Fay research based on continuous monitoring of the brand conversations of 36,000 survey participants. Experiences like live social events, tradeshows, sampling, stunts, tours, retail, and guerilla actions are highly influential according to Hayden. He also mentioned outdoor at least twice - your humble blogger noticed compelling outdoor while creeping through Boston on the way to the event (including a very distracting billboard flashing that IT IS NOW ILLEGAL TO TEXT WHILE DRIVING IN MASSACHUSETTS).

“We’ve been seduced by the illusion of accountability” in online media asserted Tom Webster, Vice President, Strategy of Edison Research. “Any given metric is meaningless until you prove it isn't” he insisted. “If you're only measuring the effect of your tweets on twitter, then you're measuring if you're good at twitter.” It is time, he stated to “stop measuring tweets and start measuring people” before, during, and after online media actions. Webster concluded that the hard work of relating online marketing to marketplace results is far from finished.

Effective B-to-B content marketing should non-promotional in tone, relevant, solution-oriented, well written, supportive of your business objectives, and provide factual proof according to Maria Pergolino, Director of Marketing at Marketo. She defined content marketing as the “creation and sharing of content for the purpose of promoting a product or service.” Proof is key to credibility in such content, she explained, because content consumers are justifiably skeptical. Pergolino provided a live example of how to manage, reuse and adapt content to new opportunities by explaining how she put her presentation together and by distributing a two-sided laminated Marketing Cheat Sheet that summarized her key points. Two attendees told your humble blogger that her presentation was "the best of the show."

Social marketing ROI is easily calculated using formulas provided by Paul Gillin, Principal of Paul Gillin Communications. He closed the event with a surprisingly well-attended and straight-forward tutorial on the topic. His simple math was based on lifetime value of a customer and conversion rates which have long been essential metrics of subscription and catalogue marketing.  Gillin's underlying assumption is that social media leads are similar to leads from other sources which has to be proven in any given instance.  But other presenters provided evidence that social media-sourced leads are in many cases more likely to convert and remain loyal so his assumption may understate the ROI.

Stay tuned for the bad and the ugly. As always your comments are appreciated.

Labels: , , , , , , , ,

Tuesday, August 31, 2010

Urgent! Pass It On: Three Big Sexy Secrets About Going Viral

Myths about going viral are part of the regular fare offered by new marketing gurus. “You create great content, and show it to ten friends who show it to ten friends and pretty soon it goes viral and a million people are looking at it.” Too bad the real world doesn’t work this way. So, what are the true secrets?

It is no secret that viral math is sexy. In the idealized scenario of each friend showing ten friends your content  and every friend showing it in turn to ten unduplicated friends, over a a million people have viewed your content in only six iterations!

But in the real world, you don’t get 100 percent response to anything.  If only one in ten of your friends show your not-so-great content to ten of their friends who behave in the same fashion, only ten people are exposed in each iteration and it will take 100,000 iterations to hit 1 million views. If the response is less than one in ten, your viewing audience dwindles to fractions in a few iterations.

The first big secret of going viral is to show your content to more than ten friends – the more the better. If only two out of ten friends who see your content then pass it on but you start with 17,500 “friends,” you’ll match the idealized 100 percent pass-along scenario and get over 1 million views in only six iterations.

Getting picked up in mass media is the next best thing to having lots of friends and a lot cheaper than buying them. Your humble blogger observes that mass media has a big role in most cases of content going viral.  How to make that happen is a subject for another blog, but for a hint see the first big secret above.

The second big secret is to use the proven techniques of direct marketing and merchandizing in your great content to attract attention and encourage response (see the tacky headline above). There infinite degrees of subtlety in doing this but even clumsy (see the tacky headline above) execution tends to work better than ignoring the experience of generations of practitioners. Ask yourself how you came to this sentence, NOW.

The third big secret is that going viral isn’t all it is cracked up to be. Great content that moves minds and results in big-ticket BtoB sales is often best delivered in person to a live audience. Events hold attention and allow substantive communication. And events greatly increase the response to the content. Your humble blogger admits that this point may seem self-serving (because it is). But ask yourself, if this assertion is not the case, why are so many marketing gurus so eager for speaking gigs and why are so many purveyors of the latest marketing technology using events to tell their stories?

So if you see new utility in these old marketing ideas: reaching big numbers, employing proven direct marketing and merchandizing techniques, and using events – pass a link along to at least ten of your friends. And if you want to prove me wrong, pass a link to absolutely all your friends – if this blog goes viral without any mass media boost, your humble blogger will confess his errors in a future blog.

Labels: , , ,

Friday, July 16, 2010

New Study: Digital Dazzle Won't Last Without Results

Virtual media is being quickly adopted by event marketers, a new Center for Exhibition Research (CEIR) study indicates. But the measurement of investment results is lagging in virtual and other types of Digital media the study finds.
 The Digital + Exhibit Marketing study to be released next week was previewed by Kurt Miller, of George P. Johnson, at the recent TS2/IAEE show in Boston. The findings are based on an online survey, now in its second year, of show producers, corporate marketers and advertisers.

Over half, (61%) of respondents are now using virtual events (webinars, live webcasts, web conferencing, events in virtual worlds and virtual tradeshows) to compliment live events vs. 36% of what Miller described as a similar sample just one year ago. More broadly, a growing majority, (78%) have faith that digital marketing (especially email) increases the effectiveness of exhibition promotion. But large portions (69% in the case of online social media) have no means to measure the impact of their digital investments.

“The talent hunt is on” for people who can create and execute digital strategy, says Miller, “Digital strategy has emerged as a valuable discipline among exhibit marketers.” 27% of respondents have digital marketing experts within their event marketing functions and 44% report the intention to build up their internal digital capacity within event marketing.

Digital media incorporates a long list of formats and actions in the study's digital taxonomy of which virtual media has to be relatively small part. In addition to virtual, the list includes:
  • Email,
  • Online banner and search advertising
  • Audio downloads
  • Webcasts
  • Online video
  • Online games
  • Websites and microsites
  • Social media sites
  • RSS
  • SMS/MMS mobility
  • Web based event management
  • Blogs
  • Google adwords
The drive to digital media is unsustainable without better measurement according to Miller. Event marketers are going to have to see and gage tangible results to keep up the pace of adoption.

Measurement isn’t much of a battle cry but we can all get behind a push for results. The incorporation of digital media into event operations reinforces event marketing’s focus on communication results. Event people, as Miller notes, tend to be production oriented. But now, new kinds of talent are required on event teams to get the communication jobs done.

The study is good news for those of us who don’t intrinsically love event details and deadlines anymore that we love the bits and bytes and endless complications of digital media. What we love is what the media can accomplish. We look at media choices as means to an end - getting good information to the right people.

As media utilitarians, we favor all forms of communication that work.

Labels: , ,

Tuesday, May 25, 2010

The Future of F2F: How to “Save” Events

Event spending is under attack. The purveyors of “inbound marketing,” SEO, and various forms of lead-generation and tracking, are advocating reallocating event marketing budgets to fuel online growth. New simulated or “virtual” events offer information seekers and marketers some of the benefits of events at lower cost.

Tech buyers are relying less on tradeshows and events for product information. According to a MarketingSherpa survey cited at marketing automation event we attended recently, 37% of the 1491 technology buyer respondents reported using tradeshows and events less often in the first half of 2009. Around 30% reported increased use of virtual events, online search, news websites, and vendor websites.

There are cyclical and secular factors to tease apart. Because the MarketingSherpa data was collected smack in the middle of a major recession, it’s not surprising that buyers said they had gone to fewer shows. (Their budgets had probably been cut.). But an internal sales and marketing coordinator we talked to during a break at the same event shared the perception: “Our leads aren’t coming from trade shows.” he asserted, “People find us on-line.”

Events aren’t facing the same grim fate as newspapers but the James Fallows piece in the June Atlantic, “How to Save the News,” is worth a read for anyone interested in “saving” the event business. Fallows looks to Google for answers - not a bad approach to any question these days.

Fallows starts with the point that newspaper subscriptions per household have been falling for sixty years as TV and other new media have gained share of mind and time. He doesn’t get into the history much, but we know that newspapers enjoyed monopoly profits that masked problems. One has to wonder if the fat margins in big events of a few years ago didn’t portend future challenges.

“Of course people will end up paying in some form,” for media of value. Fallows found zero interest at Google in the free vs. paid media debate. Google’s interest is utilitarian and empirical: “What works?” Similarly, we know F2F is valuable – from here the questions are utilitarian and empirical.

The current structure of the media business is not the result of moral failings. Fallows was surprised at how little mockery and moral superiority he heard from the Gods of Google, although he did quote a Google economist referring to the flawed business model of “grinding up trees.”. (This from a guy whose business depends on electrical power generated by grinding up and burning carbon-rich rock to boil water to spin steam turbines.) In the event business, our three-dollar sodas, five-hundred-dollar-a-day data projectors, union electricians to plug in equipment, three-hundred-dollar hotel rooms, seven-hundred-dollar plane fares and two days of travel for two days of event don’t reflect moral failings, just business problems to be solved.

The problem is not demand, it’s the business models. The Google mantra for news media, “distribution, engagement and monetization” applies to events. We need events in more places and more people at events, we need to involve them in the experience in more compelling ways and we need to find more ways to turn event participation into revenue.

The three most important things a newspaper can do: “experiment, experiment and experiment,” quoted by Fallows, are also key to the future of F2F. “Nothing works but everything might,” the maxim for the future of the news oft quoted at Google, can be applied to specific underperforming events and industry problems today.

Regardless of the new options, people will keep spending time in shared live experiences and face-to-face communication. Fallows sounds a final note about the Google faith that good solutions to almost any media problem are just waiting to be discovered. Do you have faith that there are solutions that will “save” events?

Labels: , , , ,

Wednesday, February 17, 2010

Are You Hungry for a Sale?

Some people think “selling” is a dirty word. That’s why a phrase caught my eye as I scanned the posts of an online discussion group: “People are hungry to be SOLD,” asserted Dwight Ingram, an experienced direct-marketing pro.

“Business starts with a sale.” was my motto in the early days of my event business. A savvy event guy told me I had it wrong. “Business starts with value,” he piously insisted. But I’ll stick to my guns. Until you get someone to buy, creating value is a hobby.

Selling works. People are hungry for satisfaction. A business advisor who tells you differently is probably selling you something. Watch how the advisor works and watch you own responses. I recently heard a social media expert say, “Never put your URL in a post. Let the prospect find you if they are interested.” But I’d reached him by clicking on his URL in a post!

Social media guru David Meerman Scott discounts advertising, PR and sales as the way to buy, beg or bug people for attention. He advises us instead to earn attention with online social media and “free content.” But Scott is overstating the differences.

In reality, you have to earn attention in any media that is part of your mix. Attention, however, is just the first step. AIDA is the classic mnemonic for a four phase marketing model: Attention, Interest, Desire, and Action. Attention can be fleeting - only seconds in many cases. Interest must be triggered to get beyond the first step. And interest must be nurtured to progress toward a sale.

Selling isn’t going away. Few products and services sell themselves. Whether you are using personal visits, on-line “meetings” and email, phone calls or direct-marketing media, you can’t wait for people to act, you have to help them decide to buy.

The best online media and marketing advice is essentially sales and direct marketing know-how applied to new information and communication technology. Human nature hasn’t changed.

So if you are hungry for a sale, you have to sell. And if you think events might help you sell, or if you are in the event business and need help with some aspect of generating revenue from your events, I invite you introduce yourself, by email or phone at (866) 271-9450.

Labels: , , , ,

Monday, October 26, 2009

There Will Always be a Place for Face2Face

The panic in traditional media today is painfully evident. The watchword of the day is “digital.” Old marketing and media assumptions are being tossed out. It’s not just a cyclical situation. It’s a secular change in the sense of a long-term, large scale phenomenon as big as the advent of radio or TV or even movable type. So why am I sure that events aren’t going the way of print media?

People are social animals. We like social interaction, which is one reason digital social media is red hot. The media world has been transformed by the internet and the pace of this transformation will accelerate. Human nature, however, has not changed. That is why face-to-face events, the original social media, developed over thousands of years of human experience, will remain one of the best communication tools for business.

Events are naturally engaging. You’ve heard laughter spread across a room almost instantly at a conference. Live in-person events uniquely ease exploration, create opportunities for exchange, and allow instant adjustment of your message. You can respond to the wince, the look of wonder, the wink, or the smile. You can see if your audience is paying attention or checking their email. Live events foster a level of audience concentration and focus that other media cannot duplicate.

Events are compelling. Can you recall a recent experience you’ve had, as part of a crowd? Do you remember how you felt? Chances are that your memories are visceral. People react to what they see, hear, smell, and feel. They can move around, join in and ask questions. Participation motivates and mobilizes people by powerfully stimulating the social senses.

Events build trust. Think of a person you’ve recently met, face-to-face and another you met by email or phone. Who did you get to know better, quicker? Trust is fundamental to effective communication. Trust is essential to building loyalty for your organization and brand. Trust motivates positive action. People believe what they experience first-hand. The rich experiential environment of events can be the key to building trust. People are highly receptive in an appropriate event setting.

Events make money. Even in this very tough environment profitable events are being staged every day. Well conceived and executed events deliver high returns on investment. Events effectively build relationships and convey information that leads to action. From sales meetings to major public events, these investments can pay-off consistently. Events can be a profitable media business and they are a proven cost-effective tool for communication.

Events are effective. Participants in conferences regularly credit a conference for inspiration or information. Sponsors and exhibitors come back year after year because they got their money’s worth the year before. I have had sponsors tell me that a single conversation with the right person can lead to business of a scale and profit level sufficient to justify their commitment. In our currently difficult economic climate and with the explosion of communication options, events are still a powerful tool to inform and influence high-value groups. Whether your target is employees, customers, prospects, or broader audiences, events are an essential part of your communication mix.

Meetings, conferences and other events are a vital part of any internal or external communication plan, but effectively executing a cost-effective communication initiative takes practice, focus, and expertise. In today’s demanding economic climate you need to be extra careful that your event initiatives deliver.

Face-to-face interaction will never become obsolete. Media forms will come and go, including specific forms of events, but face-to-face will continue to be a powerful media. Your use of in-person events must be deliberate and integrated with your total communication effort to get maximum value from them. But you can be completely confident that there will always be a place for Face2Face!

Labels: , , , ,